How to Choose Between a Docking Station and a Hub ~ Plugable Technologies

Yes, there is a difference, and picking the wrong one could mean IT chaos! Or at least some extra cable wrangling.

There’s a recurring question when managing fleets of laptops, tablets, and mobile workers: do you give them a full-blown docking station, or a lightweight hub?

It depends on the scenario. Let’s walk through the decision tree so you can pick smart, save time, avoid support tickets, and preserve your cable ties.

What’s a Hub and What’s a Dock?

What is a Hub?

A hub is essentially an extension of a port (often USB-C or USB-A) that gives you extra downstream ports. Think: “I have one USB-C on my laptop, but I need three USB-A’s, an HDMI, maybe an SD reader, maybe Ethernet.” A hub will often do that. But with caveats: it usually draws power from the laptop (rather than supplying the laptop), supports fewer displays, fewer high-end features, but tends to be smaller and portable.

What is a Docking Station?

A docking station is the heavyweight. It’s designed to turn a laptop (or tablet) into a desktop-like workstation. Expect multiple monitors, full-sized USB-A and USB-C ports, Ethernet, audio jacks, SD/microSD slots, and most importantly, a dock will usually power the host device. Bonus if it supports Thunderbolt or USB4 and high-res displays.

In short, a hub is a port expander for mobility. A dock offers more ports, features, and (usually) powers everything.

Buy the Plugable Thunderbolt 5 Dock with 3x Thunderbolt 5 Ports, 140W Laptop Charging
List Price: $299.95

Add to compare

Use-Case Scenarios

Scenario 1: Road Warrior / Hybrid Worker

Need: Lightweight laptop, travels between home, coffee, office. Occasionally needs a monitor, keyboard, mouse, maybe Ethernet if WiFi is flaky.
Solution: A hub fits nicely. Portable, not too heavy, decent ports. The user throws it in a bag, takes it with them.
Why: It doesn’t need to power the laptop fully, display demands are moderate, the desk setup is temporary.

Scenario 2: Dedicated Desk Setup for Power User

Need: A laptop acts as their workstation. Two or three monitors, USB-C peripherals, wired Ethernet, external storage, full-sized keyboard/mouse, maybe charging the laptop too.
Solution: Go with a docking station. One cable to plug in when they sit at the desk; unplug when done.
Why: Simplifies transitions, supports the display and power demands, reduces cable clutter, and support calls.

Scenario 3: Shared Workstation / Hotdesking Environment

Need: Multiple users plug into the same desk (hotdesking, clinic administrative station, meeting room). They bring their device, need to connect quickly to monitors, keyboard, network.
Solution: Docking station again. Standardized one-cable connect/disconnect experience.
Why: Efficiency, fewer mistakes, predictable support environment.

Scenario 4: Minimal Setup / Secondary Device

Need: A tablet or Chromebook used occasionally, doesn’t need multiple monitors or heavy peripherals.
Solution: Hub. Keeps cost down, simple.
Why: Anything more is a waste.

Buy the Plugable 9-in-1 USB-C Hub with 4K HDMI, 140W Pass-Through Charging
List Price: $49.95

Free 3-Day Shipping on Orders Over $35!

Direct purchase in most US states. Currently excludes AK, IL, KY, MI, NJ, and OH.

Amazon US ($49.95 USD)

Some Humorous (But Real) Pitfalls to Avoid

Buying a hub for someone who insists on “plug this one cable and I’m good.” And then they plug in their two 27″ monitors, USB video capture device, external drive, and… nothing works properly.
Choosing a dock that doesn’t support host charging, so the laptop still needs its own charger. Result: more cables, more confusion.
Buying a hub for your power-hungry laptop that relies on "pass-through" charging. The hub may consume 15W–20W+ just to run its ports, leaving your laptop to charge slowly, or even slowly discharge, under heavy load.
Buying a “universal” hub/dock that doesn’t support the OS or doesn’t support multiple monitors on macOS (because of MST or DisplayLink quirks).
Deploying a different model for each user and having 12 different cable types; standardisation is your friend.

Recommended Workflow for IT Managers

Create tiers of user profiles (e.g., “mobile”, “desk power user”, “shared station”).
For each profile define minimum specs: number of monitors, power delivery wattage, peripherals required.
Choose one hub model and one dock model (or one per profile) and standardise. Keeps support simpler.
Document the “just-plug” procedure: which cable connects, which port on laptop, how to undock.
Train users. “If you just need extra USB and an HDMI for travel, use the hub; if you set it and forget it at the desk, go dock.”
Review periodically: If the user’s role shifts (e.g., from mobile to desk full-time) upgrade their kit accordingly.

Q: What’s the biggest difference between a docking station and a hub?
A: Power and performance. A dock is designed to run your workstation — power, displays, peripherals — all at once through a single connection. A hub is more like an extension cord: great for travel or quick access, but not a full replacement for a dock.

Q: Can I use a docking station with multiple laptops?
A: Yes, absolutely. That’s one of their biggest advantages. Just make sure each laptop supports the connection standard (USB-C, Thunderbolt 3/4, or USB4) and has the right drivers if the dock uses DisplayLink. In shared or hot-desking environments, docking stations simplify setup dramatically — one plug and you’re ready.

Q: Do docking stations work with MacBooks?
A: Yes — but check the details. Macs don’t support MST (Multi-Stream Transport) for multiple extended displays over standard USB-C, so you’ll want a DisplayLink-based dock if you need two or more external monitors, especially on M1 through M3-based Apple systems. DisplayLink technology works by compressing the video signal and sending it as data over a standard USB connection. Because it handles the video processing outside of the main computer chip (GPU), it bypasses operating system limits, allowing devices like MacBooks to support multiple extended external displays. Plugable has several Mac-friendly options that get around this limitation.

Q: How many monitors can I connect with a hub or dock?
A: Most hubs can support one external monitor (sometimes two if you’re using DisplayLink or Thunderbolt). Docks typically support two or three monitors, depending on the chipset and your laptop’s GPU capabilities. If your user needs multiple 4K displays, go for a Thunderbolt or DisplayLink dock.

Q: Are docking stations worth the higher cost?
A: If you’re setting up permanent workstations or equipping power users — definitely. They save time, reduce cable clutter, and extend laptop lifespan by minimizing wear on ports. For occasional use or lightweight travel setups, a hub is usually sufficient and more cost-effective.

Q: Can I travel with a docking station?
A: You can, but it’s not ideal. Docks are built for desks — they’re bulkier and need their own power adapter. A compact USB-C hub is far more travel-friendly and will keep your bag lighter (and your TSA experience smoother).

Q: How do I know if my laptop supports a dock?
A: Check for a USB-C port with DisplayPort Alt Mode or Thunderbolt 3/4 logo. Those support video, data, and charging — the trifecta that makes docking stations shine. If your laptop only has USB-A ports, you must use a DisplayLink-based dock that connects via USB-A .

Let’s Get Connected

In the end, the difference between a hub and a dock comes down to scale and purpose. If your user’s workstation is basically “one dongle for everything, I travel 3 days a week”, a hub probably does the trick. If they’re anchored at a desk, with multiple monitors, high-speed storage, Ethernet, full USB arrays, and expect the laptop to charge while doing it, then a docking station is the productivity ally you want.

Choose smart, plug once, and let your users work with fewer cables and fewer complaints.

View Other Articles in Category

Business, Docking Stations, Personal Use, Productivity

Loading Comments

_{Article ID: 746132734183}